• About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
Wednesday, October 8, 2025
  • Login
Vital News
  • Frontpage
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Politics
  • National
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • More
    • Crime
    • Judiciary
    • Security
No Result
View All Result
  • Frontpage
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Politics
  • National
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • More
    • Crime
    • Judiciary
    • Security
No Result
View All Result
Vital News
No Result
View All Result
Home Judiciary

Kogi Guber Tussle : APC, Ododo, INEC Ask For Dismissal Of SDP Petition, Tribunal Reserves Judgment

Vital News by Vital News
May 13, 2024
in Judiciary, Politics
0
Kogi Guber : Tribunal Orders INEC To Allow, SDP, Ajaka Lawyers Access To BVAS, Other Election Materials
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), on Monday, prayed the Kogi State Governorship Election Petition Tribunal sitting in Abuja to dismiss the petition filed by the Social Democratic Party (SDP) and its governorship candidate, Murtala Ajaka, against the election victory of Gov. Usman Ododo of Kogi State.

Similarly, Ododo and his party, the All Progressives Congress (APC), also adk the three-member panel of justices, headed by Justice Ado Birnin-Kudu, to dismiss the petition in its entirety for being incompetent and lacking in merit.

The INEC, APC and Ododo made this submission before the tribunal on Monday in Abuja through their lawyers; Chief Kanu Agabi, SAN; Joseph Daudu, SAN and Emmanuel Ukala, SAN.

They asked for the dismissal of the petition while adopting their final written addresses and presenting their arguments against SDP and Ajaka’s petition.

However, Ajaka’s lawyer, Pius Akubo, SAN, urged the tribunal to discountenance the respondents’ submissions and uphold their petition.

RelatedStories

President Tinubu Accepts Departure Of Yakubu As INEC Chairman, Bestows CON National Honour On Him

Acting Chairman Of INEC, Agbamuche-Mbu, Promises To Uphold Standards, Integrity , Professionalism

Agbamuche Becomes INEC Acting Chairman As Mahmood Yakubu Serves Out Tenure

I Am Under Intense Pressure To Contest 2027 Governorship Election In Taraba — David Kente

The tribunal after listening to all the parties in the petition, reserved the matter for judgment.

It would be recalled that Ajaka had challenged Ododo’s victory in the Nov. 11, 2023 Kogi governorship election.

In the petition, INEC, Ododo and APC are listed as 1st to 3rd respondents.

The tribunal had, on April 25, fixed today for adoption of final written addresses after parties closed their case in the matter.

Upon resumed hearing, INEC’s counsel, Chief Agabi, told the court that their final written address was dated and filed on May 2.

He said the commission’s reply on point of law was dated May 8 and filed May 9.

While adopting the processes, the senior lawyer submitted that the petition lacked merit and incompetent, urging the tribunal to strike it out or dismiss it.

“It is our humble submission that your work in the determination of this petition is simplified in recent judgments by Court of Appeal and Supreme Court,” he said.

He argued that Appeal Court had decided that if the grounds of a petition are inconsistent with one another and are not consistent with the reliefs, it should be struck out.

He also argued that the evidence of the petitioners were grossly insufficient, citing a Supreme Court decision in a case by Tonye Cole against INEC.

“It is to the effect that once the evidence called is grossly insufficient, there is no evidence.

“In that case, the petitioner filed 305 witness depositions but only adopted 40 of them.

“The petitioner, according to the decision, only adopted about 13.1 per cent of the witness depositions.

“In this case, the depositions adopted represent just about 3.6 per cent of their witness depositions,” he said.

He said the petitioners only called 25 witnesses out of the scores listed.

Agabi said in mathematical calculation of evidence, 3.6 per cent of Ajaka’s witness deposition adopted in the petition amounted to a failure and therefore, ought to be dismissed.

The lawyer also described the petition as frivolous.

He said the petitioners equally failed to file the witness deposition before hand in contravention of the Supreme Court’s decision in Obungado’s case.

He argued that the petitioners’ witness who testified about the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS) machines clearly stated that he could not guarantee whether those were the BVAS used.

Besides, he said the witness was not the maker of the inputs in the BVAS machines.

“Also, the evidence contained in the BVAS machines fell short of what is required of the law,” he added.

Agabi further argued that the BVAS machine was tendered against Section 84 of the Evidence Act, as there was no certificate of trustworthiness attached alongside it as required by the law.

He argued that out of the 25 witnesses called by the petitioners, there was no single polling unit agent among them.

“In other words, not a single person who observed the election was called.

“Besides, the star witness could not distinguish between what he heard and what he saw when questions were put to him,” he said.

The senior lawyer prayed the tribunal to strike out or dismiss the petition for being incompetent.

While adopting his final written address dated and filed on May 1, Daudu, who appeared for Gov. Ododo, urged the tribunal to dismiss the petition in its entirety.

He argued that the petition was statute barred (filed out of time).

The senior lawyer said though the petitioners responded to their submission that “when it comes to filing, it is what the secretary of the tribunal says that determines the date of filing.”

He, however, argued that the action of the petitioners was against Section 122(1) and (2)(a) of the Evidence Act, which empowers the tribunal to take judicial notice of this.

But Akubo objected to Daudu’s citing of the section describing it as fresh argument.

Daudu, in response, disagreed with Akubo that he was raising fresh issues after a final written address had been filed.

“You cannot shut me out from making my comment.

“You cannot because you don’t have the power to do so,” he said.

He said if the court found merit in his argument, Akubo had the right to respond because it bordered on issues of remittal procedure.

He also urged the tribunal to dismiss the allegations of forgery against his client, saying it bordered on pre-election matter, which the apex court had decided in Gbagi’s case against INEC.

Daudu also argued that Section 137 of the Electoral Act cited by the petitioners on allegations of over-voting did not apply in the instant petition.

Also backing Daudu’s submission, Ukala, who represented APC, urged the court to dismiss the petition for lacking in merit.

The lawyer, who said their final written address, dated April 30 was filed same date, adopted all the processes.

The petitioners’ lawyer, Akubo, told the tribunal that their final written address was dated and filed May 6.

He disagreed with Daudu that their petition was filed out of time.

He argued that the respondents themselves confirmed that the petition was filed on December 2, 2023, even by their own witness.

“I urge your lordship to hold that we filed this petition within time under our law,” he said.

After taking the arguments, Justice Birnin-Kudu reserved judgment in the petition which he said would be communicated to parties.
(vitalnewsnhr.com)

 

Tags: APCBVAsINECOdodotribunal
Previous Post

Abiodun Congratulates Tobi Amusan On Jamaican Invitational Triumph

Next Post

UNILORIN Appoints 40 New Professors

Vital News

Vital News

RelatedStories

President Tinubu Accepts Departure Of Yakubu As INEC Chairman, Bestows CON National Honour On Him
National

President Tinubu Accepts Departure Of Yakubu As INEC Chairman, Bestows CON National Honour On Him

October 7, 2025
Acting Chairman Of INEC,  Agbamuche-Mbu, Promises To Uphold Standards, Integrity , Professionalism
National

Acting Chairman Of INEC, Agbamuche-Mbu, Promises To Uphold Standards, Integrity , Professionalism

October 7, 2025
Agbamuche Becomes INEC Acting Chairman As Mahmood Yakubu Serves Out Tenure
News

Agbamuche Becomes INEC Acting Chairman As Mahmood Yakubu Serves Out Tenure

October 7, 2025
I Am Under Intense Pressure To Contest 2027 Governorship Election In Taraba — David Kente
Politics

I Am Under Intense Pressure To Contest 2027 Governorship Election In Taraba — David Kente

October 7, 2025
Kogi Set To Mark 10-year Memorial Anniversary Of Ex- Governor Abubakar Audu
News

Kogi Set To Mark 10-year Memorial Anniversary Of Ex- Governor Abubakar Audu

October 5, 2025
Next Post
UNILORIN Appoints 40 New Professors

UNILORIN Appoints 40 New Professors

Go After Terrorists, Restructure Nigeria Now – Afenifere Urges Tinubu

Tinubu Directs Mandatory Purchase Of CNG - Powered Vehicles By MDAs

14 Abuja-bound Passengers Kidnapped In Kogi , Police In Rescue Mission

Six More CUSTECH Students Rescued From Kidnappers

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow Us

Recommended

Okun Group Commends Sen. Karimi, Hon. Abejide, Hon. Salman Idris For Quality Representation

10 months ago
President Tinubu Postpones FEC Meeting In Honour Of Late COAS, Gen. Taoreed Lagbaja

President Tinubu Postpones FEC Meeting In Honour Of Late COAS, Gen. Taoreed Lagbaja

11 months ago

IGP Condemns Attack On Female Police Officer, Orders Express Prosecution Of Prof., Others

3 years ago
Purported Rift Between Me And Gov. Abiodun, Imagination Of Fifth Columnists, Says Sen. Olamilekan Adeola

Purported Rift Between Me And Gov. Abiodun, Imagination Of Fifth Columnists, Says Sen. Olamilekan Adeola

2 years ago

Instagram

    Please install/update and activate JNews Instagram plugin.

Categories

  • Agriculture/ Water/ Mineral
  • Aviation
  • Business
  • Crime
  • Culture
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Environment
  • Football
  • Foreign
  • Gender
  • Health
  • Judiciary
  • Labour
  • Maritime/ Marine Transport
  • National
  • News
  • Oil & Gas
  • Opinion
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Power
  • Religion
  • Security
  • Sports
  • Tourism
  • Transport
  • Uncategorized

Topics

Abiodun Abuja APC arrest Atiku Bandits Bello Benue Buhari CBN cement Court Dangote death dies drugs Economy EFCC Election elections FG gunmen Hajj INEC Kano kidnap Kill Kogi Kwara Lagos NDLEA Niger Nigeria Ododo Ogun Oyo PDP Police Power refinery rescue road Security students Tinubu
No Result
View All Result

Highlights

History As Governor Abiodun Inaugurates First Flight At Gateway International Airport

Dangote Refinery : FG Berates PENGASSAN For Holding Nigeria To Ransom

NCDC Chairman, Akighir, Promises Equitable Distribution Of Projects, Interventions Among States In North Central

EXPLORING CHINA’S YUNNAN AND ITS COFFEE HAVEN : Travelogue By Lawal Sale

Agbamuche Becomes INEC Acting Chairman As Mahmood Yakubu Serves Out Tenure

I Am Under Intense Pressure To Contest 2027 Governorship Election In Taraba — David Kente

Trending

President Tinubu Accepts Departure Of Yakubu As INEC Chairman, Bestows CON National Honour On Him
National

President Tinubu Accepts Departure Of Yakubu As INEC Chairman, Bestows CON National Honour On Him

by Vital News
October 7, 2025
0

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu has accepted the departure of Professor Mahmood Yakubu’s as the Chairman of the...

Amid Allegation Of Certificate Forgery, Geoffrey Uche Nnaji Resigns As Minister

Amid Allegation Of Certificate Forgery, Geoffrey Uche Nnaji Resigns As Minister

October 7, 2025
Acting Chairman Of INEC,  Agbamuche-Mbu, Promises To Uphold Standards, Integrity , Professionalism

Acting Chairman Of INEC, Agbamuche-Mbu, Promises To Uphold Standards, Integrity , Professionalism

October 7, 2025
History As Governor  Abiodun Inaugurates First Flight At Gateway International Airport

History As Governor Abiodun Inaugurates First Flight At Gateway International Airport

October 7, 2025
PENGASSAN Members Shut Down NNPC, NUPRC, NMDPRA

Dangote Refinery : FG Berates PENGASSAN For Holding Nigeria To Ransom

October 7, 2025
ADVERTISEMENT
Vital News

Vital News is an online newspaper with a mission to uphold professional journalism by reporting and publishing only facts and figures-based news reports across Nigeria and beyond.

Recent News

  • President Tinubu Accepts Departure Of Yakubu As INEC Chairman, Bestows CON National Honour On Him October 7, 2025
  • Amid Allegation Of Certificate Forgery, Geoffrey Uche Nnaji Resigns As Minister October 7, 2025
  • Acting Chairman Of INEC, Agbamuche-Mbu, Promises To Uphold Standards, Integrity , Professionalism October 7, 2025

Categories

  • Agriculture/ Water/ Mineral
  • Aviation
  • Business
  • Crime
  • Culture
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Entertainment
  • Environment
  • Football
  • Foreign
  • Gender
  • Health
  • Judiciary
  • Labour
  • Maritime/ Marine Transport
  • National
  • News
  • Oil & Gas
  • Opinion
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Power
  • Religion
  • Security
  • Sports
  • Tourism
  • Transport
  • Uncategorized

© 2022 Vital News - . All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Frontpage
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Politics
  • National
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • More
    • Crime
    • Judiciary
    • Security

© 2022 Vital News - Vital News by Vital News.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In